MRAs and trans ultras: two cheeks of the same arse

MRA and trans ultras are two cheeks of the same arse. Surely not? One is of the right and the other the left, surely. But look at the similarities.

Both groups are looking for ways to turn identity politics and victim culture to the advantage of white beta males, who feel collectively short-changes by a hierarchy of victimhood that seems to give some measure of coveted victim points to pretty much everyone except them. Both are also looking for ways to legitimise their resentment at women’s unfair exclusion of them from the sex they all imagine other males are having.

The giveaway is the strong smell of embittered sexual entitlement and the apoplectic rage specifically at being excluded *by women* – both MRAs and trans ultras respect and accept the threats of violence with which they are excluded by alpha males.

The difference between the groups is that where MRAs rage at identity politics and victim culture, ranting about the rapist immigrants and feminazis who seem to get preferential treatment from this system, trans ultras seek to appropriate the structures of the victim/identity system to become the most oppressed group ever in the history of oppression and hence claim some victimy goodness for themselves. But both are responding to the same cultural structures (identity politics and ‘intersectionality’ aka victim culture) from the same set of resentments (perceived loss of privilege within the current victim hierarchy, resentment at own sexual inadequacy and lack of sexual access to women). And both groups use very similar rhetorical tactics: trolling, doxxing, if necessary physical violence.

There is a reasonable and legitimate movement to ensure gender nonconforming people are treated well by a society that largely does not understand them. I support this movement.But it has been colonised by a mutant strain of MRA beta-masculinity, that has renamed itself ‘trans-femme’ to avoid confronting its own abjectly low rank within a male-supremacist gender hierarchy that these males have accepted without question.

These people are the Islamists of the trans movement, parasitically inhabiting what would otherwise be a movement of peace and liberation and turning it instead into a war of revenge on every woman who ever looked dismissively at them and moved on.

Author: The Sparrow

I’m UK-based. I’m interested in the political and cultural side-effects of globalisation, the replacement of class politics by identity politics, and the emerging backlash against the regressive left. I was a radical lefty once upon a time, though these days I'm just interested in following arguments wherever they go. I voted Leave, in the interests of positive, engaged globalisation within a democratic framework, though I'm a bit exasperated at how it's going so far. I’m a fan of liberty, free speech, home winemaking and practical feminism.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s